Sociologica
N. 1/2008
Doi: 10.2383/26579
Copyright © 2008 by Società editrice il Mulino, Bologna
Commentary
Comment on John Goldthorpe & others/4
“Cultural Capital” or “Cultural Resources”?
Abstract
In this paper, I try to strike a brief balance concerning the discussion between Goldthorpe and his critics appeared in the second issue of Sociologica. After examining the main criticisms presented to Bourdieu’s concept of cultural capital, I maintain that this notion is still a useful devise to construct a general theory of social stratification. Surely, the concept – especially in its first formulation in 1970 – lacks precision and is pervaded to a certain extent by ideological biases. Nevertheless, Bourdieu’s theory of social mobility places power as the central key to sociological analysis, and this aspect makes his approach a valuable and fruitful contribution.
Keywords:
Goldthorpe, cultural capital, social mobility, sociological theory, power.